“What are you?”

I get asked this question all the time, wherever I go. “What are you?” I got so tired hearing it that I once answered on a whim: “Guess!” The man who had asked me proceeded to list off all the Asian nationalities he knew: “Chinese, Japanese, Thai, Indonesian, Indian, Mongolian…” It was around the tenth guess, that I nodded. Oddly, he was not satisfied with my answer. To be honest neither was I. He looked at me incredulously and walked away. I felt his disappointment, perhaps he was hoping to achieve some sort of confirmation for his painstakingly-built system of racial order, at the very least, he made a good effort to pin me down.

In all honesty, I don’t really know what I am. On paper, I am a two-time immigrant, my husband is also an immigrant and my children are even more multicultural and multiracial than I am. However, inside, in my mind—my idea of self, I don’t use a specific race or even the term “multicultural” to define myself or my family.

As a child, I was often surprised when someone pointed out that I was something definite, something different from them: “Asian”, “Chink”, “Foreigner”. It felt so odd to be so enclosed within a word, like I occupied a space—a space as small as their tongue. A coin perhaps, my value etched on the surface: gender: female, race: Asian, worth: half a regular person?

The hardest part for me growing up as an immigrant in the US was that my identity was so malleable, so unformed. As a child, when I was confronted with bigotry or when someone disrespected me outright, I could not separate it from my own sense of self-worth. My parents were ill-equipped to help me; they were authoritarians who instilled in me the idea that the best reaction to hostility was compliance. So when someone called me names, labeled me at first glance, I often put my head down and tried to make myself disappear. I hid from name-callers and if I couldn’t avoid them, I tried to act as non-threatening as possible. This was very painful for me growing up, it felt like I was slowly suffocating in a dark, narrow box, unable to communicate that I was a human being—a human of intelligence, value, emotion. If I were to disappear no one would ever know that I ever existed in the first place.

This feeling of suffocation would engulf me whenever someone treated me like an inferior or whenever they said that I didn’t belong. A particularly poignant experience was when I was sixteen years old, attending high school in Seattle. My English teacher, Mrs. V., who normally spent class time chatting jovially with the popular kids, strolled the aisles one morning and casually asked everyone: “What does it mean to be an American?” We were all silent for a long time, then she specified, “Who is an American?” A cheerful boy answered, “Everyone who lives here is an American, immigrants too. They can be Americans if they live here and work hard.” A few of the other kids nodded in agreement, but Mrs. V. was not satisfied with his answer. She continued roving the room, searching for another opinion.

A tall, sporty boy raised his hand and she nodded. “No,” he said firmly, “Only whites and blacks are true Americans. Everyone else is a foreigner.”

This answer made Mrs. V. stop still. Several kids in the room nodded, agreeing with him.

“Why?” Mrs. V. asked.

“Because only whites and blacks contributed to this country, they made the country what it is today: the most powerful country in the world,” said the boy confidently.

As he spoke, he gave all the nonwhites and nonblacks in the room an icy look. It was then that I realized why that particular boy always ignored me—even when I spoke to him directly, and why he only associated with an exclusive group of people. His eyes caught my gaze and his lips curled in disgust as he looked back at me. It was as if he was daring me to contradict him, as if any rebuttal coming from me would be automatically self-serving and feeble.

“You’re wrong,” yelled another outraged student vehemently, “That’s not true! Other races have contributed too!”

But Mrs. V. interrupted her, “No, no,” she said, “I didn’t call on you. He’s entitled to his opinion. Everyone is entitled to form their own opinions.” With that she put an end to further discussion.

That was the only time that nationality was ever brought up in my high school.

At the time, I felt a hot rage boiling inside me, some of it at the boy, but most of it at Mrs. V. It was one thing to have an opinion when you weren’t informed, everyone could form an opinion with little knowledge, but she was our teacher, it was her job to educate us. She did not question the boy or challenge him in any way, merely nodded and accepted his opinion, in the name of “showing everyone respect”. She did not question or even explore the meaning of “race” or the meaning of “contribute”. She did not question why a newly born or newly immigrated white or black person could take credit for the accomplishments of other people purely on the basis of shared skin color or ancestry. And if they took credit for all the accomplishments of their so-called race, why not all the failures too? Should a son be praised or punished for the actions of his father or his grandfather? She said nothing about the accomplishments of other “races”. Nothing about the interdependency or cooperation of countries in the world. Nothing.

Throughout my life this would be the kind of prejudice and complacency I would be confronted with in many forms. I became well-acquainted with certain views of immigrants as pests, leeching off the wealth of the country and degrading the purity of national identity. There have been crude and underhanded attempts to demean me—the micro-aggressions of daily life. Extended staring, hateful looks, refusal to talk to me, balky service, complaining about foreigners in my presence, these are all the ways I can expect to be treated when carrying out daily tasks.

I have also been treated to impromptu lectures, as if I represent a whole country of wrongdoers. My presence has become an outlet for the grievances of globalization. When I vacationed in Alaska, several fishermen glared at me as they loudly complained of the Japanese overfishing the waters. In Germany, a baker complained vociferously about the “Chinese destroying small European bakeries by flooding the market with cheap flour and baked goods.” I have tried to see it with compassion, tried to find the kernel of validity in their overwrought fears. But I strongly doubt I could fix things if I actually was a citizen of either of those countries, or even if I was an employee in either of their companies. I doubt I could even secure my own job from outsourcing (I have lost a job in this way myself). These kinds of big decisions affecting jobs and resources are out of any individual’s control. I would have better luck if I was a room full of CEOs, or a computer projecting numbers from the stock market. But it’s so much easier to blame a defenseless person than a computer or a boardroom—to scapegoat a foreigner than the actual, less tangible culprit.

Advances in technology and transportation have shortened the once great distances separating nations, separating people. In many ways, the changes have been positive, my life as I know it today and the important relationships I have made would not have been possible without technology, especially the Internet. Major cities now boast the wealth of cuisine, art and knowledge from a kaleidoscopic array of cultures around the world. But the pervasive hostility that I have encountered as an immigrant has shown me that our minds, our ideologies have not kept up with these changes. And there are, of course, the all-important negative changes: companies and jobs are now as movable as emails, everything seems to have lost its permanence, opposing cultural beliefs are brought to friction by their now close proximity. I can understand the desire for stability and security fueling the anger behind populist and nationalist movements, it is the same desire that immigrants know all too well.

In my experience, bigots do not differentiate between a legal or an illegal immigrant, when it comes down to it, all migration is considered wrong because “everyone should stay within their own country”, this is an argument I have heard often. I have been likened to a traitorous opportunist for failing to stay within the borders I was born in. I can feel the rage and fear behind the hate, especially in this time of terrorist threats. I can hear the note of despair behind the yelling and the insults, the primal desire to go back to a simpler time, to simple rules, to simple borders on a map—the simple desire to sort people by their outward appearance or religion.

After all, I am sure no one wants to their identity, their sense of entitlement, their sense of worth, their connection to the land—to the earth itself to be tested in the ways mine has. The cumulative experience of being a two-time immigrant was akin to putting my identity in a blender and spinning it at maximum. Whatever positive attributes I thought I had, whatever good I thought I could offer society, whatever values I had cultivated in my previous home, all of it would be put to question under the corrosive effects of prejudice and social isolation until one day I came to a stunning realization: I realized that I had unwittingly absorbed all that hate over the years. So much hate, that when I looked in the mirror, I didn’t recognize myself anymore. What I saw was a worthless person, foreign, ugly, pathetic, a burden in all aspects, not worthy of anyone’s time or respect. But then I looked closer, there one more thing about my reflection that became glaringly obvious, it was definitely a clear reflection, but not of me. The answer to “What are you?” was staring at me all along: I am you.

“What are you?” For people determined to hate me, there would be no answer good enough, no argument valid enough, no amount of information could prove that I was their equal. They saw only that ugly thing, a monster of their own making: a taker of jobs, a waste, an inconvenience. For people who genuinely wanted to get to know me, they also saw their own reflections: a person of value, worthy of respect—a possible friend. Obviously, I can’t actually say, “I am you” without inciting some sort of dramatic reaction. So whenever anyone asks me that question now, I just reply with whatever comes to me in the moment. Then I watch that other person, I really watch them and it’s them I can see.

The forces of hate, the online trolls, the bullies of the world may think they have recently won sweet victories; they may feel emboldened, empowered, validated. There may be nothing anyone can do to stop them or change their minds. But what they don’t realize is their cover has been blown. If you ever find yourself the victim of unprovoked hostility or if you ever witness someone spewing degrading insults, ask yourself this: Who is really being exposed here? Who is really being described? I guarantee you, you will find it is not the victim being defined. No one is qualified to assign another person their value.

Martin Luther King Jr. dreamed of a world where people would “not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character.” It may be too stupidly idealistic to say that a tolerant, inclusive society is a peaceful one, but he succinctly outlined the important caveat of such a freedom, “the content of their character”. No one, be they black or white, Muslim or Christian, man or woman, straight or gay, should impede on the rights of another. Protecting refugees, allowing immigration, striving for equality, treating humans as humans—these are not burdens but privileges. What country, what nation, what people in the history of the earth has ever really strived to uphold that beautiful ideal that “all men are created equal” or respected the rights of the “other” if they were not forced to? Can it even be possible? Now, perhaps for the first time in history, in the midst of unprecedented economic and technological change, countries that have suddenly become more diverse are poised to answer that question. Some have already answered with a resounding no. But for the future of my children, I strive to belief that these are not victories but the death throes of an obsolete and antiquated ideology.

Hate, racism and supremacy is a negation of life, a denial of a shared reality. It is to impose false assumptions, hierarchies and beliefs over Nature itself. Somewhere in the distant past an important decision was made that altered the course of our development as humans: Figuratively speaking, Eve made the decision to eat that apple. She chose knowledge. We, her children, irrationally strive for the simplicity and the ignorance of the past, to go back to an idealized time. But what if we stop trying to make anything great again? What if we stop denying reality its true form—stop denying anyone their humanity? What if we stop trying to go backwards and finally digest that apple?

 

alightcirclewebsiteinferiorsuperior2mpbaecker

Text and images by M.P. Baecker © 2017

A very big, heartfelt thank you to Bryce Tache and Discover for sharing this article!

In response to all the positive feedback I have received for this story, I have written another story The Mirror of Love.

160 thoughts on “The Mirror of Hate

  1. This is one of the best articles I have ever read. It reminds of my country kenya where tribalism is the order of the day and you are categorized to a tribe by your name or your skin color. There was this particular day I had gone to my department in campus to see my Econ lecturer. His secretary looked at me then at my name and since she could not tell which part of the country I came from/which tribe I belonged to, she asked me. I told her what I tell everyone else-I am Kenyan and insisted on it even when she nagged me to tell her where I came from exactly.
    In the end,she became very angry and served me half-heartedly.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Thanks so much for reading and for your kind and thoughtful comment!

      I notice prejudice everywhere in the world too, not just in the US or Germany. I have been called names or inexplicably gotten bad service in many places all over the world, especially from government bureaucrats, I’ve been calling it the “back door” treatment, everyone has a “front door” for the honored guests treated with courtesy, and a “back door” for those they find less worthy or less valuable than themselves. This is terrible and needs to stop, but it would take conscious effort on everyone’s part to unlearn judgements, prejudices often reinforced by institutions and cultures, especially in places with a history of oppression, racism, or a strict class system. Maybe it will never stop, but we cannot let it get us down or let it affect how we see ourselves or our own value!

      A major reason why I wrote this article was to find people like you and me who have experienced prejudice, to help them cope and even thrive in the face of this kind of hostility. I am glad you stood your ground and did not tell her your tribe, I admire you! I sometimes cave in and tell people the answer they are expecting to hear from me because I get tired of their questioning. But these people are just scared of someone not fitting into their definitions, it can be scary to admit you really don’t know who someone is, but ultimately, treating humans as humans is its own reward. Going through life actually living, with a mind for learning, a heart for loving, and not letting the fear of the unknown set your limitations, that’s the best life ever!

      Thanks again! It means so much to me that my story resonated with you!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I like to try to think the best of others rather than separate a crowd of people into social stigmas and differences. It’s been harder and harder to think the best of people in the time we live in. But I still like to think people are mostly good.

    Thanks for sharing!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks for reading and for your thoughtful comment!

      You make a good point, it is important to not let bad experiences and past traumas affect how you see other people that you become negative or hateful yourself. It is important to give people a chance, to allow them to define themselves without immediately casting them into a role or a stereotype. I think by not internalizing the negative experiences, by not accepting them as “normal” or just “the way things are”, but seeing them as a reflection of the other person’s misjudgments or failures, one can shield oneself from this negativity.

      Ultimately, it is everyone’s responsibility to make the effort to acknowledge everyone’s humanity. After my painful journey, I learned to look for the best in people and focus on that!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. It’s teachers like her that scare me so much. If only they knew how much of an impact they have on students. If she challenged the student, it would show you and possibly others that she’s open-minded, not many people think in a hateful way and that she is safe to talk to if needed be. Also with bullying when teachers ignore it and pretend it doesn’t exist. It can have a huge impact on the student getting hurt. It just makes me cringe hearing stories like these when a teacher or the school can prevent hatred or a bad situation, but choose to just let it happen. I enjoyed your blog, keep fighting and know not everyone is full of hate!

    Liked by 2 people

    • Thanks so much for your lovely comment!

      You are so right, teachers can have a huge impact on a person’s life, from the school years to beyond. It is one of the most important jobs. Yet, some teachers get burned-out by it, or they fail to see the significance of their contribution to society and the world, so they go about their job mindlessly like Mrs. V. Looking back on it, I don’t really think Mrs. V. was a deep-thinking or very conscious teacher. She, like several other bad teachers I encountered, condoned and even fueled bullying, they impressed the belief that society had a natural hierarchy and bullying was just a manifestation of putting people in their rightful place.

      I’ve also had several great teachers in my life, without their contribution, I would not be where I am today. I’ve also experienced great kindness from people in many difficult situations in my life, without their help I would not be alive today. And with this story, I’ve experience great sympathy and encouragement from people all over the world, like you! Your positive comments mean a lot me! Thank you so much for reading!

      Like

  4. This was such a moving essay. It’s so raw and passionate; honest and inspiring. I wish experiences like yours weren’t so prevalent in this country. You have a unique gift for being able to dig deep within yourself, and articulate emotion through the written word in a way few authors are capable of achieving. There were moments where I was reaching for a tissue. I know it sounds like an empty platitude, but I am deeply sorry your teacher did not advocate on your behalf as a young student. I can empathize, but I’ll never truly understand how awful that must have felt in that moment. But at least you can say, they were all wrong about your value to society. Your writing is proof you have a gift that would have made this world a darker place were it not utilized. Thank you for sharing your experience with the world.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Thank you for your incredibly beautiful comment!

      The experience of sharing this very personal story has made me feel more vulnerable than fighting a many-headed dragon with my bare hands! But the overwhelmingly positive response and thoughtful commentary has astonished and completely awed me, and also humbled me in ways I cannot express. It has been like looking into another kind of Mirror: A Mirror of Love this time! I am trying to compose an eloquent response to the kindness and generosity of all the readers but now find myself often at a lack of words!!!

      THANK YOU for your kindness and for reading!

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Very insightful article I totally agree with you people are so judgemental of everything around them This does not happen just in America it happens everywhere … but I have come to realize in life don’t change your path for what people have to say as they will always have something to say .

    Liked by 2 people

    • Thanks for your lovely comment and positive words! You are so right, one must focus on the path one really wants in life, everyone will always have an opinion. Focusing on what’s really important to you is key to disempowering hate and negativity!
      Thanks for reading!

      Liked by 1 person

  6. I thoroughly enjoyed this, as an immigrant whose had many issues growing up, i feel so deeply your experience. I’m writing a live novel in the form of a word press blog about existentialism and the human condition. Feel free to follow me. I hope my writing inspires emotion like yours has in me.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Thanks so much! I took a quick look at your blog and it is superb! I like the writing, the music and look forward to read more from your live novel!
      I think our experiences as immigrants need to be explored and shared more, politicians or other vocal personalities try to exploit the immigrant identity, thinking we cannot fight back because we have no voice. I am glad my voice resonates with so many people!
      Thanks for reading.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Thank you so much, honestly it may not sound like much, but as I get started, it’s the early support that really humbles me. It’s the moment of truth lol, the-“am I any good or do I suck..and let me tell you.. Your words legitimately took me some where. They were poetic. This piece you wrote feels like a piece of English composition that students would dissect for literature.

        Liked by 2 people

        • Thank you! Your support means so much to me as well!
          I always have that negative voice telling me that I’m not good enough too! I think every writer and artist does! It’s important to have that voice there because it can help us to edit or polish our work, but we have to keep it controlled and caged, we have to exploit it and not let it exploit us!
          I hope you always keep writing and sharing I really look forward to reading more of your work!

          Liked by 1 person

  7. I have been through this phase when sometimes I used to look at myself in the mirror & hated the person I saw there, not because I really hated myself but, because people made me do that.
    It is really difficult to prove that your colour does not depict what you are.
    But even after years, those jokes & comments,it still happens & sometimes it bugs me a little bit but not as much as it used to because it does not depict what I am. Those comments reveal what they are.
    Loved your article. 🙂

    Liked by 3 people

    • Thanks for sharing your experiences. I hope that by describing these painful experiences, I can communicate the negative impact prejudice, racism and exclusion has on an individual. I especially want to empower those whose claim to a nation or identity is challenged in this way. We’ve both been through this, and sadly, it will continue and still continues for us and for many people all over the world. This is my way of shielding myself, my core, from hate. I can’t control everything, perhaps I can’t make the world a less dangerous place for my children, but I can give them this armor, this shield against hate.

      Liked by 1 person

      • It is really difficult to make people understand that making racist jokes or comments does not make them funny or cool.
        I have had a number of failed attempts. I hope this article brings a change.

        Liked by 1 person

  8. Thank you. I see myself in this, too. I used to try to make myself invisible, thinking if I were, I wouldn’t be able to feel the stares or the comments. I had a teacher that called my mother in for a conference when I was in 4th grade because I “wasn’t as athletic as all of the other black kids”. She told my mother I may need counseling. I am by no means comparing our circumstances, but I am saying that I recognize the seeming futility of it. It is a feeling of otherness, even though we are all part of the same global tribe. What we have to remember, I think, is that there are more of us who want to foster unity, than those who want to destroy it. Thanks again for your wonderful post.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Thank your for your kind words and sharing your experiences! I really appreciate reading about other people’s experiences with prejudice and exclusion. This is sadly, still going on everywhere. It upsets me very much. I noticed some of my friends growing up being mistreated or labeled by teachers and counselors just based on their race, I remember one moment in particular when a counselor, without even asking, just went up to the Hispanic students and said “Go to college after high school okay?!” he just assumed they were not planning to go to college! He also said the same thing to me! It felt like a slap in the face and it was an uphill battle for me to explain to him, “Well I do plan to go to the University, I just don’t know how to apply. I really need your help with the paperwork.” But what if I didn’t confront him or get his help? People’s lives can be severely affected by this kind of prejudice.

      Thanks for reading!

      Liked by 2 people

    • Thank you for your lovely comment!
      It means so much to me that this article resonates with many people. It was really hard for me to finally get myself to write it and share it, the negative experiences in my life have often managed to convince me that my opinion doesn’t count, that I am a nobody. But I am glad I didn’t listen and I shook off that negativity.
      Thanks for reading!

      Like

Comments are closed.